Oct 24, 2024 5:12 PM
*excuse me, areological
I'm almost done with Blue Mars now too, so some of the review might be about that, but they're basically one big book.
In the best LeGuin tradition, Robinson is unashamedly political, and even has some mini-fables in there about the perils of scientists trying to act apolitically. What those politics are, exactly, does not seem quite as considered. The books are deeply concerned with climate change, but take the lazy Malthusian/pro-austerity/misanthropic view of humanity's role in it; they are scathingly critical of the massive power of mega-corporations, but feature a friendly, surf-loving billionaire taking on a massive role in liberating Mars out of the goodness of his heart; they are constantly thinking through experiments in socialist, egalitarian governance, but can only manage to cite past examples of socialist success when White people did them.
While Mars trilogy does have those ambitious overarching plot points, it more often reads as a collection of thousands of little thought-experiments about all the branches of science often ignored by sci-fi in favor of faster-than-light travel or whatever: geology, hydrology, materials engineering.
So my (probably too curmudgeonly) political gripes aside, I found this to be a pretty hopeful antidote to capitalist realism. Centuries-old hierarchies crumble away in ways that seems obvious in retrospect (but aren't dismissive towards of the real-world struggles against them). The sheer joy of possibility in creating a new world (in every sense of the word) suffuses both the process of negotiating a constitution for a free Mars and a character going for a hike or tending a garden. And it is all underpinned by the picaresque quality of characters flitting from one slightly-fantastical engineering project (houses in giant bamboo shoots underneath a glacier) to another (giant lens floating in space concentrating a ray of sun to melt away rocks into super long canals). Overall, I put it above Aurora but below Antarctica. Also I'm pretty sure every Robinson book I've read has had public bath house sex scenes which is kind of funny.