Feb 22, 2025 4:49 AM
The old man's fourth major work of traditional literature, if we count the Nobel Lecture, which we should, and easily his most normal. Tarantula is interesting, taken to be unrecorded outtakes, an eyeball into the impressionistic image-making of 60s Dylan, but kinda shit as the poetry it is advertised to be. But Chronicles and the lecture are bullshit classics, self-portraits painted in jet black, partisans of self-imposed and unanswered questions, trading in rampant intertextualism and/or plagiarism and/or fabrication. The mythos of Dylan cannot survive the straightforward introspection autobiography requires, and so it fights back against the very forms it's agreed to write in.
Philosophy of the Modern Song is not autobiography. It's a simple, not-in-any-meaningful-way organised collection of articles about, you guessed it, songs. But, it is the nature of this kind of analysis, this kind of light canonising, this kind of storytelling, that it would reveal something about the person writing it. And it does; ironically, I've never felt that I've learnt more about Dylan, the actual guy, than I have while reading this book. Unfortunately, I've never really wanted that. Dylan's persona need not a corporeal form, and while it's cute and all when he thanks the Dunkin Donuts folks or tells a niche showbiz story or compares a rockabilly song to opera or whatever, I'm not sure it's worth seeing him so naked. I didn't really want to know that he's such a normal 83-year-old guy, bothered by the term 'Okay Boomer,' feeling left behind in modern culture, divorced and very bitter about it, of the firm belief that the great modern art is all of his youth, and so on. Not to say it's a bad read. The man can turn a phrase; these articles are compelling, and the prose-poem statements of interpretation that precede them are a worthy experiment. Still, this is a Robert Zimmerman book, and it offers up the approximate pleasures of a Robert Christgau book. Best as I can tell, he didn't even rip any of it off from Spark Notes this time. What's the point!