Apr 06, 2025
What happens after the conquest? When Indians are dead or on reservations, cattle are in ranches, and rangers become ranchers? What's left is the Earp family, Doc, Charlie Goodnight (now a rancher) and dulled glories. Once again, everything is over; everything is always being over. An uneasy vacuity remains.
The writing is very different from the Lonesome Dove series. Everything is refined, minimalist: interior life is briefly sketched (while LD would offer paragraphs and repetitions on the matter), and in the end, the book barely reached 200 pages (LD installments average around 600).
I couldn't tell if this economy of words works because of the relative celebrity of the characters (even a non-American would have met them in quite a few western films), which fills in the blanks, or if it works only because the author manages to say a lot with few.
2 Comments
9 months ago
As a McMurty diehard, would you recommend reading the series in chronological or publication order?
9 months ago
Publication order is fine for Lonesome Dove. As I said elsewhere, the last published book is only the second in chronological order, but it feels like an ending. By then, the two main characters are already old rangers; "afterwards", they are former rangers, so this is a different life.