The City and The City really caught me off guard, going into the book I expected Mieville to be writing something similar to the works of other authors I am going to group together as "scifi/fantasy with literary reputations", that is authors like Gene Wolfe, Samuel Delaney, Dino Buzzati and plenty of others I am forgetting at the moment. In these cases those authors write very good books that traffic in genre fare with the reputation that there is some kind of transcendental stylistic element or major literary influence that sets them apart from your Brandon Sandersons or Robert Jordans. So going in I was expecting something on those lines, but much to my surprise despite the odd setting the book is almost entirely a straight noir, and even more surprising to me that was the greatest strength of the novel.
Recent reviews
Recent lists
Recent writings
✦
✦
✦

Love the review. As mentioned, the Borges connection is so spot-on. At one point in the novel when the “.uq” URL extension was mentioned something clicked for me about how reminiscent of Tlon, Uqbar, and Tertius Orbis so much of tC&tC felt. Also really agreed with your impression of the strength of genre here. Miéville seemed really wonderfully upgrade of this book being labeled a police procedural/noir piece and that lends itself to the experiment really well. And then the lack of explanation around the Cleavage and lack of actual sci-fi mechanism around the split really is the strongest trait of this book, I totally agree. There are question left at the end, not hamfisted “lore.”